Archive for the ‘Florida DUI Courts’ Category

DUI Official Reports: Unique to Each Offender… or Not

Monday, March 26th, 2012

In the event that you were arrested for a DUI-related offense, you might think that an official report concerning your charges would be unique to you and your case.  However, this is not the case as more and more law enforcement officers have begun to use a template or pre-written form for each arrest.  These reports are supposed to be specific to each motorist arrested, and because they are signed under oath by the arresting officer they are subject to any perjury charges.   You might also think that being subject to perjury charges would encourage officers to not only submit genuine arrest reports, but to care about the reports and the implications they might carry.

The unfortunate reality is that if your case goes to court and the arresting officer has to testify in front of a judge he may very likely find himself at a loss for memory of the specific arrest.  In this case, he will go back to the pre-written form/template that he filled out.  Rather than filled out an official report that is specific to your case, complete with everything surrounding your case; the officer who arrested you may have decided to “cut corners” and fill out a form.  Since the arresting officer probably will not remember the specifics about your case, he/she will quickly review the pre-written official report, hoping that the quick review will jog their memory.  Only it doesn’t and the officer gives a testimony based on a faulty report.  The officer then, in effect, perjures himself as he stands before a court of law and testifies under oath.

In a case originating in Florida, the defendant’s attorney successfully requested a court order from the Highway Patrol for any forms that the arresting officer used when the DUI arrest was conducted.  The Highway Patrol turned over a document entitled “field sobriety test,” which appeared to be a template.  This document appeared just you might expect a template to, including spaces to fill in the name of the driver, the weather conditions, the location of the stop and subsequent arrest, the environment the field sobriety test was given under and a very narrow empty section specifically designed for the officer to describe their observations during the field sobriety testing.

Typically, arrests do not occur as set sequence of events.  There is no plotline or script to follow.  Each arrest is different and unique to the offender.  Unfortunately, official police reports pertaining to DUI arrest rarely, if ever, reflect this.  An experienced Florida DUI attorney would work tirelessly on your case and refute any evidence deemed as misleading, including “templated” police reports.

If you or someone you love has been arrested or charged for a Florida DUI, the experienced Florida DUI attorneys at Musca Law have helped many people avoid the extremely harsh consequences of Florida DUI convictions.  We invite you to contact a Florida DUI attorney at Musca Law to schedule a free confidential consultation: (800) 687-2252.

Court Ruling Cast Doubt over Use of Florida Breath Test Results

Friday, April 15th, 2011

The Florida Supreme Court has made it more difficult for Florida prosecutors to prevail in DUI cases where breath test results constitute the strongest evidence against a driver charged with driving under the influence of alcohol.  The state’s highest court affirmed lower court decisions in Sarasota and Manatee counties ruling that those accused of DUI are entitled to review computer code inside the Intoxilyzer 8000 to analyze how the machine works.  The Intoxilyzer 8000 is the only breath test machine approved for use in Florida for DUI breath testing.  However, CMI, the company what makes the machine, has refused to provide the information on the grounds that it is an important trade secret.  CMI’s position has placed prosecutors in the position of having to agree to reduced charges or in other cases agree to dismiss hundreds of DUI cases during the last few years.

Prosecutors insist that even without release of the machine’s source code, they can still use the breath tests but it means more time and incurring the additional expense of flying in an expert for trial at the rate of $1,000 per case.  Florida DUI defense attorneys have indicated that there are hundreds of Florida DUI cases that may be impacted by the court’s ruling that the code for the machines must be provided.  This may continue to be a valuable tool for Florida DUI defense attorneys because CMI does not seem ready to relinquish the source codes anytime soon.  The company has incurred an estimated $2 million in fines for contempt of court as a result of the company’s refusal to comply with court orders to produce the computer code.

Even prior to this ruling, there were many legal strategies an experienced Florida DUI attorney could use to challenge breath test results.  There are a number of reasons that breath test results can be inaccurate.  The machine often measures chemicals with molecular structures similar to those found in alcohol.  According to Dr. David Hanson, there are in excess of a hundred substances can be found in the human breath at any one time, and 70 to 80 percent of them contain a methyl group structure and will be incorrectly detected as ethyl alcohol.  Diabetics, for example, have extraordinarily high levels of acetone, a substance that some breath machines mistake for ethyl alcohol.  Women are also more likely to register a false positive breath test.  Some breath machines are preset based on a specified hematocrit, which is the percentage of whole blood that is composed of red blood cells.  Men typically have hematocrit values that exceed those of women, and many breath test machines do not account for the gender of the person providing the sample.

The ruling by Florida courts have added to the shaky nature of DUI cases that rest primarily on breath test results.  If you have been arrested for DUI anywhere in Florida, you should contact an experienced Florida DUI attorney who may be able to use the Florida Supreme Court’s ruling or other legal or factual arguments to have your breath test excluded and your charges reduced or dismissed.

Call 1 (800) 687-2252 For a Free Consultation With a Florida DUI Lawyer In Your Area

Hiring a Florida DUI attorney to aggressively defend you can help you obtain the best possible result in your case.  Call our toll-free, Florida DUI Helpline at 1 (800) 687-2252 or search our Florida DUI Lawyer directory for a law firm near you (by appointment only).

Free eBook – How To Beat a DUI in Florida:

Florida DUI lawyer discusses the ways in which someone charged with a DUI in Florida can fight their DUI charges and possibly win their a DUI trial in Florida. Click Here For How To Beat A DUI in Florida.