Archive for the ‘Bicycle DUI in Florida’ Category

Bicycling While Driving Under the Influence

Wednesday, July 27th, 2011

Recently in Florida, an arrest and conviction of a DUI charge can not only occur while driving a motor vehicle, but also by simply driving a bicycle. While the news has left many wondering whether or not this is a joke or not, sources say it is actually more common than many people know to be arrested while operating a bicycle while being under the influence.

However, an issue at the time pertaining to bicycling and operating it under the influence is a bit different than when driving a motor vehicle. Generally, when driving a car, just by driving you give an implied consent to participate in a DUI field sobriety test when a law officer requests it, as printed on a driver’s license. Yet, you do not need a license to drive a bicycle. The Florida stature pertaining to driving while under the influence is very broad in saying that a DUI is when a “vehicle” is involved. In stating that, a bicycle is a mode of transit in which can we used on public roads, streets, or even highways, but is not a motor vehicle. Also, there have been many varying arguments about bicycles being able to ride aside cars and share the roads with them, which poses a possibly traffic delay, and a hazard to safety to other drivers and pedestrians.

When it comes down to the actual suspension of a license while dealing with a DUI charge, a motor vehicle operator is really the only person eligible for the suspension, as previously stated, a bicyclists do not have to hold a valid or a license period to operate the bicycle. When it comes to the court of law, usually there is a split or heavy debate as to whether or not a driver’s license suspension is possible to a citizen who committed to the misdemeanor of driving while under the influence while not operating a motor vehicle.

In 1987, the state of Florida dealt with such an issue in the third District Court of Appeals. Based on the statue, the DCA concluded that the Florida legislature had a very broad, undefined definition of a vehicle when it came to driving while under the influence. Even today, the Florida Supreme Court has still not clearly stated whether or not a driving while under the influence charge can be committed as an act on a bicycle.

Call 1 800-687-2252 to Speak With Florida DUI lawyers In Your Area.

Hiring Florida DUI lawyers to aggressively defend you can help you obtain the best possible result in your case.  Call our toll-free, Florida DUI Advice Helpline at 1 (800) 687-2252 for a Florida DUI law firm near you (by appointment only).

Can You Get A DUI Riding A Bike In Florida – Florida DUI Lawyer Answers

Tuesday, April 12th, 2011

The police and prosecutors in Florida take DUI charges very seriously.  The way Florida’s DUI penalty framework is set up is designed to strongly discourage recidivism (i.e. repeat offenders).  Unfortunately, sometimes the application of law becomes somewhat detached from meaningful real world policy and yields somewhat misguided results.  If a person has a serious drinking problem and has been convicted twice of a Florida DUI within the last 10 years, the person might decide that it is important not to get a third DUI offense, which could result in a ten year suspension of one’s driving privileges.  This is a laudable goal that should be encouraged.  Unfortunately, Florida DUI law does not distinguish between driving a 10,000 pound pickup truck and a 60 pound bicycle.

In Florida, a person may receive a DUI conviction for riding a bicycle with a blood alcohol level that exceeds .08 percent, the level at which one is legally presumed to be too impaired to drive under Florida DUI law.  The driver is deemed “per se intoxicated” with a blood-alcohol level at or above .08 percent. This means that drivers with a BAC at or above .08 are intoxicated in the eyes of the law, and no additional proof of driving impairment is necessary.

The relevant DUI law in Florida provides that if a person’s BAC is at or above .08 percent and he or she engages in the following conduct, the person may be charged with DUI:

A person is guilty of the offense of driving under the influence and is subject to punishment as provided in subsection (2) if the person is driving or in actual physical control of a vehicle within this state

The terms “driving” and “vehicle” are construed very broadly under Florida DUI law.  A Florida court construing this law in the context of a bicyclist charged with DUI indicated that the law applies to ANYONE in physical control of a vehicle.  The court also found that a vehicle as referenced in Florida’s DUI statute included any device by which a person may be transported upon a Florida roadway.  A conviction for DUI of a bicyclist has been upheld based on this reasoning.

The wisdom of such a broad interpretation of Florida’s DUI law is arguably misguided.  Presumably, the rationale behind tough drunk driving laws is that vehicles that weigh several thousand pounds and move at speeds of 70 mph can cause massive carnage, catastrophic injuries and fatalities.  A person who drives a motor vehicle under the influence of alcohol in Florida puts the safety and lives of others in danger.  However, an intoxicated bike rider presents far less of a danger to others on the roadway.  It may be a bad idea to ride a bike while intoxicated, but the greatest danger is to the bicyclist own safety.  One might ask is it not better to have a person who has a habitual problem with alcohol on a bicycle where they pose much less danger to others?

Misguided or not, Florida DUI law does allow for a driver to be arrested and convicted for DUI if their blood alcohol level is at or over .08 percent.  While it is unclear whether this means you will also be arrested for DUI in Florida if you are driving a horse drawn carriage, it might be a good idea not to test the law.  If you are arrested for DUI for driving any vehicle in Florida, you should seek legal advice from an experienced Florida DUI attorney.

Call 1 (800) 687-2252 For a Free Consultation With a Florida DUI Lawyer In Your Area

Hiring a Florida DUI attorney to aggressively defend you can help you obtain the best possible result in your case.  Call our toll-free, Florida DUI Helpline at 1 (800) 687-2252 or search our Florida DUI Lawyer directory for a law firm near you (by appointment only).

Free eBook – How To Beat a DUI in Florida:

Florida DUI lawyer discusses the ways in which someone charged with a DUI in Florida can fight their DUI charges and possibly win their a DUI trial in Florida. Click Here For How To Beat A DUI in Florida.